Originally posted by El Framo:
Printmaker,
If you don't mind me asking, which machine did you choose, and why. No real reason, just curiosity.
I'll have to agree with Bob here: "This ought not evolve into a Chevy vs Ford, Boxers vs Briefs debate."
With one of my earliest postings here, and with the best of intentions, I presented some "inside information" on a particular (now defunct) CMC. I inadvertently ticked off a fellow grumbler (in a major way!), who owned one of these, and thought it was the absolute "cat's meow".
Getting back to Bob's comment, selecting a CMC is very much like choosing a car. Some of us look at style, some at function. Some ask friends. All of these are valid. I recall reading a study a while back, where Corvette owners were amongst those with the highest customer satisfaction rating - this, even tho' the Corvette was near the bottom of the heap for overall quality and dependability. But if someone is happy, who is to say that he/she should not be!?!
As we always buy new cars, I tend to research the h-ll out of model. I seek out "the experts", and ask independant mechanics. I'm not as swayed by happy owners who have driven their vehicles for 40,000 miles. I'm more interested in finding out how the vehicle will be at 100,000, or 200,000, or beyond. But that's me.
Back to your original question(s), El (and Bill), without going into details, of the 3 models (4 models, actually ... 3 brands) eliminated:
- one was eliminated because of (what I perceived to be, for OUR PURPOSES), basic design flaws in the machine, itself, and also software shortcomings (again, these "shortcomings" were due to a lack of things that WE needed the machine to do),
- one was eliminated due to overall quality of construction and "robustness" (or lack thereof),
- the third (and 4th) were eliminated due to obvious and blatant customer service problems (in our area).
The 2 CMC's we finally chose between were the Eclipse Pro, and the Valiani Future (now the "Fletcher/Valiani Future"). This posting is already too long, so I'll leave off by saying, if I still owned a custom frame shop, I'd have purchased the Eclipse. As 95%+ of the work we frame is my own artwork (for reasons specifically aaddressing OUR needs), we chose the Valiani...
Even though we are pleased with our choice, and would purchase another (under the Fletcher name) without hesitation, I have highly recommended the Eclipse Pro to a number of framers who have approached us...
And even though we will never ever own a Wizard, I have, in the past, recommended Wizards for particular framers for whom, IMHO (okay, it's not all that "humble"
), this machine was ideal.
Back to work now - I have a tonne of mat cutting waiting for me. I'll be pressing my index finger to the bone
.