Originally posted by Jason:
...I am looking at the new Fletcher 5600 and the ITW/AMP VN2+1...I am currently using a thumbnailer and have read on previous posts that after a while the nails pop out and ruin the frame. Is this true?
Jason:
The Thumbnails won't just "pop out" if the frame is properly glued, but the plastic inserts can break if the frame suffers an impact sufficient to knock the the glue joints loose -- allowing the frame to fall apart.
V-nailing is definitely a better way to go. Like other major framing tools, most of us don't get to use a lot of V-nailers, so we tend to really like what we learn to use well.
The VN2+1 is a good machine, and has been around a long time. I had one in the early 90's and traded it for a VN-42.
The Fletcher 5600 is very similar, but a newer design. Both are Italian machines, and well made. However, I think you'll find that the Fletcher is lower priced. The VN2+1 has not faced such direct competition before, and Fletcher is aggressively promoting their new product line.
Other than the price difference, Fletcher machines have the advantage of their extensive distribution network. When you need V-nails or accessories, you can buy them from almost any Fletcher-Terry distributor.
About six months ago I sold my VN-42 in favor of the Fletcher 5700. No regrets, and I like all of the extra features.