PPFA Framing Competitions

FramerDave

PFG, Picture Framing God
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Posts
5,415
Loc
Houston, Texas
There was a topic started yesterday about different types of dust cover material, and a couple points were raised with regards to the framing competition. They were good questions, so to keep the other discussion on-topic I though they might make for good discussion on their own.


what has been stated, PLUS, you will NOT be considered for an award if you use kraft on a PPFA piece(no matter how good the reast of it is)---you MUST use acid free stuff(even on the back sheet)

As I understand the competition guidelines, nothing is really absolutely required. You could enter a piece framed with regular glass and brown kraft paper if you wanted. You just can't expect to do very well.

Kraft paper is everyday, average, and the judges would mark it as "expected" or lower. To get the judges' attention and get the kudos you need to take it up a notch to something like the Lineco paper or Tyvek. Judges really like it when you use something out of the ordinary that still meets all the criteria. I can't think of an example offhand, but it's a good thing when you hear them say "Oh, I never would have thought of that!" and "Hey, come over here and look at this."


Do the judges open up the frames to check the whole thing through and through? I would think that they would just to be sure that the whole package, not just the backing paper was "up to snuff".

No, they don't dissect the frames. A framing description form is required, listing all the methods and materials used and why. So for the parts that aren't visible I suppose there's a little bit of the honor system at work.

The guidelines call for the framer to use the best possible preservation, but aesthetics is the name of the game. For instance, back in March there were a number of print competition entries whose mounts had failed. Not surprising considering its awkward shape and the shipping involved. Chris Paschke, who at the time was the chair of the Competition Board, suggested that competitors might sacrifice a couple points of preservation in favor of getting the entry there in one piece.

By the way, during the Master Certified Picture Framer exam the candidate's work is dissected and examined closely. That's kind of the point of it, being an exam of technical knowledge and preservation skills rather than design.

So, are you entering the print competition this year? Most chapters judge in October, so there's still time.
 
When judging, I expect buffered backing. You would lose points for any kind of kraft paper. But, that alone might not cost you the competition.

Too tight or too loose wire (assumign another hanging system wasn't used) could cost you points. There are lots of things that could cost you points and lots of things that are opportunity for extra points.

It's not just "Stunt framing" that wins competitions.
In a recent competition I judged the "simplest" of the entries won. BUT, it was nearly perfect in everything that was done.

The description form in the competition is key! If there is a question about something not explained in the description form most judges I have seen (including me) assume that "common practice" was used. This isn't always a good thing in a competition.

Good topic Dave!

P.S. competing is a huge win to your business. I invite costomers to comment on my design considerations for almost a month. Even do things like try "their frame selction" on the competion piece. I've had customers come back after the chapter competition just to see how "we" did. (THEY use the pronoun 'we'!) Then you get to use the competition piece for display - win again!

PPS oh shoot, FYI, I am an Approved PPFA Judge
 
"Every competition is won or lost on the description sheet."

and I am a Credentialed PPFA Judge

As for Kraft, I and many other judges would mark it down.... yes, it's the everyday ubiquitous backing.... but this is competition and in the handbook, if in not so many words, then the intent is to treat the image or object as very valuable and frame accordingly. Inferring "conservation" level of framing.
 
Back
Top