OKay, here's how far I will go to please a client. I ordered the same profile in a different color. I removed most of the paint with acetone, then re-painted to match what they wanted. Only took an extra 20 minutes. Sidebar, I finally caved and we pulled LaMarche from our walls until things shape up. I'm sure I'll still have to match an old order from time to time, but at least I won't have almost daily frustration trying to find mouldings!